Straw Man Arguments Against The Evolution Of Mental Health

15. We oppose the psychiatric system because it is frighteningly similar to the Inquisition, chattel slavery and the Nazi concentration camps.

25. We believe that the psychiatric system is, in fact, a pacification programme controlled by psychiatrists and supported by other mental health professionals, whose chief function is to persuade, threaten or force people into conforming to established norms and values.

26. We believe that the psychiatric system cannot be reformed but must be abolished.
Statement of Principles from the 10th Annual International Conference on Human Rights and Psychiatric Oppression ; May 1982, republished on MindFreedom.org

“Any such officer or person may at any time, and shall be permitted so to do by the authorities thereat, visit and inspect any psychiatric facility, and in so doing may interview patients, examine books, records, and other documents relating to patients, examine the condition of the psychiatric facility and its equipment, and enquire into the adequacy of its staff, the range of services provided and any other matter he or she considers relevant to the maintenance of standards of patient care.”
Subsection 9(2) of the Mental Health Act of the Province of Ontario

“An Advocate shall ensure that clients are fully informed about advocacy activities undertaken, about information which is gathered in the course of advocacy and about reasonable alternatives, implications of actions and potential outcomes. Unless required by law, and subject to available resources, an Advocate shall not withhold relevant information from the client.”
Standards of Practice for the Ontario Psychiatric Patient Advocate Office

“I don’t believe, however, that just because one has a diagnosis of a mental illness that they need medical treatment. I probably should, if I believe that they’re biologically based. But I think it’s a sliding scale, like anything else, and that not everyone is affected to the same extent. Some people can get by without, some people don’t want to take medication because they like how they are, some people don’t want to take medication because they don’t trust it, and some people respond better to therapeutic treatments.”
“Am I pro-psychiatry? Well, not exactly.”; Pole To Polar, Nov. 17, 2008

“Call it a disorder long enough and people without the disease start believing that all we need is a hug, maybe a car ride and a Stephen Colbert marathon and we’ll snap out of it. And if we don’t, well then it’s because we’re just loving the attention or something.

“The combination of genetics and imaging technology is allowing researchers to prove Manic Depression is a disease passed on by mother and father and that it infects the chemical syringes in our heads, so that the controls on ‘how much’ and ‘when’ are set to ’shuffle’ and ‘repeat’.

“Clinical and Normal Depressions have direct and reasonable causes. Manic Depression has neither. Depression is something forced on us by the disease.”
“Frequently Unanswered Questions”; Me.

There are no cures for manic depression, or any other mental illness, and anyone who says there is or they have one is a fraud.

There is no doubt about this. No reputable company, university or researcher can claim to have more than a treatment or hope for one. Yet a small but very vocal group of people want you to believe there are people, specifically psychiatrists, claiming to have a cure. This straw-man argument allows this group of people to then claim psychiatrists, and the medications they prescribe, are frauds for claiming there are cures.

Many of these people using the straw man argument, after telling you psychiatrists are frauds, will then pitch the idea manic depression can be treated or even cured using natural methods, such as vitamins, amino acids or Lithium Orotate — which is not the Lithium commonly used to treat manic depression.

Manic depression, they’ll tell you, is not a disease. Neither are other mental illnesses, for that matter. Which is what their argument is really about: psychiatrists are frauds for telling you there’s a cure for what ails you, but what they tell you is a disease is really just a state of mind which can be overcome with better nutrition.

Continue reading

Posted in Bipolar, Bipolar Disease, Bipolar Disorder, Classic, Clinical Depression, crazy people with no pants, Health, Manic Depression, Politics, Psychiatry | 27 Comments

My Thanks To You On The Second Anniversary Of Salted Lithium… YAY YOU. Again.

The second year of Salted Lithium ends today. I doubt very much I would have continued blogging beyond November 17, 2006 if it hadn’t been for people reading and commenting.

So once again I thank each and every person who commented. By participating, by asking questions and leaving answers, by encouraging me, you’ve helped fix some things which were very wrong. And you’ve helped me walk through some of the worst moments by proving to me there are people who care, and showing me examples of people who have walked where I have walked and come out the other side better for it.

Over the past few weeks I’ve been publishing posts representing what I think are the central themes I’ve been writing about: the relationship I’ve had with my father; my fight against manic depression, and; the moments of my life I’ve shared with friends and family. A little further down you’ll find quotes from, and links to, some of those posts.

In between here and there are the photos of the people who have allowed me to put their images in my sidebar over the past two years. Each photo is a link to their blog. I highly recommend subscribing to each of them… even to the few who have stopped blogging. Maybe we can get them going again.

…I’d also like to thank bromac and dumbwaiter, neither of whom have blogs, but both really should start so I can put them in my blogroll beside the other people who have helped keep me walking.

Specifically, though, I need to thank Clare for being here since the beginning…

Continue reading

Posted in Bipolar Disease, Bipolar Disorder, crazy people with no pants, Health, Manic Depression, Second Salted Anniversary | 17 Comments

No Post Day | Hair Today Gone Tomorrow

We may not always put them to their best use but the genes in my family are pretty good. However, there’s a definite possibility I’m losing my hair… which should make my little brother happy.

On my mother’s side there’s definitely male-pattern baldness going on. My uncle, and my grandfather were both left with the horseshoe pattern before they were fifty. My grandmother has been wearing wigs since before I was born, and my younger brother’s hair has been visibly receding for a few years now.

On my father’s side there’s a few burnt out counterrevolutionary’s running around with most of their hair, albeit some of them have been left with the tight, pencil-width ponytail. From what I remember my grandfather still has most or all of his hair left.

For the past few years I’ve been getting my haircut every five months, but I’ve decided to let it grow back to where it was four years ago. Except for a couple of high school “scene/emo” kids this means, for a dude, I now have the longest hair in my village…

I’m not sure if I’m doing this because I’m sick of having short hair, or because there’s a part of me getting prepared to have a proper comb over.

I still haven’t decided what I’d do if I start losing the hair. My brother has gone with the “shaved head” response. My friend Justin has gone all the way bald, but he’s got the thick beard/goatee going.

.

So my questions, for anyone willing to play along, is:

For both the ladies and the dudes: what would your response to hair loss be, or what has it been?

Bonus points: If you could have anyone’s hair, whose hair would you have?

.

...thanks.

.

Posted in crazy people with no pants, Health, No Post Day | 25 Comments

Setting Fire To My Father’s Paper Trail

“…my father believed he was a great man who was in the middle of a great revolution, and things get sacrificed during revolutions. Like family…. The truth is pretty simple, however, my father told lies that corrupted and nearly killed the people who trusted him.”
“A Lying Maoist Revolutionary Con Artist Stole My Family…”; June 25, 2007

In the city where he lives my father is celebrated as an advocate for the poor, he shelters the homeless and fights with all of his considerable intelligence and guile to make life better for the disenfranchised.

Every few months the newspapers in the city where my father lives will write a feature, or an article, featuring both him and his fight against poverty. Each one adds to the myths my father has created to mask the devastation he has brought to my family.

My father was the leader of a small, but determined band of Marxist True Believers, which included my mother, his youngest brother, and their friends. Ten years after it had begun my father had managed to betray and humiliate everyone who cared for him, and everyone who believed in him.

My father’s protection from being exposed as a philanderer, a pathological liar and a comes from the guilt and shame of the people who could expose him for what he has done. My father’s infidelities began while my mother was in the hospital recovering from the birth of my younger brother, from which she almost died.

Eventually they ended several years later with the revelation my mom’s best friend was pregnant with my youngest brother, and the dissolution of both his marriage and the political group he had started.

After eight years of believing in him, in his vision, he was exposed as being the leader of his own sex cult. Yet somehow he has managed to rehabilitate his image so that, thirty years later, he is being Sainted by the local newspapers.

And if someone, someone who used to stand beside him, were to raise an objection or write a letter to the editor exposing some of my father’s behaviours, their own involvement would be exposed. “Sure, I’ve done some pretty stupid shit,” my father would say, “but they followed me right into the pile.”

And if I were to stand up and say “here, this is my father’s name and here is what he has done”, then who gets caught up as collateral damage? It took my mother twenty years to recover from the damage caused by my father. She’s respected in her community, she does not deserve to relive any piece of any of the horrors she lived through.

Or what about my two little sisters? They grew up not knowing anything about their three brothers. Of course, he couldn’t tell them. He couldn’t tell anyone, because then the questions would start, questions he still can’t answer.

Last year a reporter asked him about his family. He says he is “proud of them”.

But the reporter didn’t ask “how many”. So my father was able to respond using the kind of vague word games he loves so much.

According to the same feature his backstory is missing seventeen years.

In the years after the divorce my father put together groups which collectively own huge amounts of property which house people with no other place to go. According to some of these articles he has raised over a million dollars to protect other people. But nothing about the seventeen-year gap ever appears in any of the stories written about my father.

My father went, within just a few years, from being a man who had spent eight years ignoring his children, cheating on his wife and someone who had betrayed everyone, to being the father of two adoring daughters and a fighter of injustice and poverty in his community.

In order to make his new life work, if he wanted to save himself, he couldn’t tell people about the detestation he had caused. He couldn’t have people knowing he never paid child support, or that he had a son he had never met. Because good fathers sacrifice for their sons, they don’t sacrifice them.

My father has pretended to be a revolutionary for over thirty years. It’s how he has always seen himself. But my father was never a revolutionary. Revolutionaries sacrifice for their cause, but he never had a cause beyond his own self-preservation and the only thing my father ever sacrificed was me and my brothers.

My father calls himself an alcoholic now. But no one I’ve interviewed who knew him as a younger man can remember him drinking, and there was a strict “no alcohol” rule in the collective. My father has always told stories about his past. Almost all of them are lies, and the ones which are true have become even more distorted each time he tells them.

And still he remains protected because his victims, by exposing his abuse, also expose themselves as having been victimized. The infidelities which started while he was with my mother, continued into his relationship with the mother of his two daughters.

He allowed his daughters to grow up thinking he was a hero in his community. A man who could do no wrong. Then, because our meeting was becoming inevitable, he told them about their two brothers. Then left it to us to tell them about their third brother.

In many ways they’ve become estranged from him as they try to reconcile the father they knew with the man he has been exposed as. And as they do this he is still considered a hero in their community. And their separation from him becomes another sacrifice he can point to as proof of his heroic credentials.

Look at how he can endure. The people in his life abandon him and still he continues to save the lives of others. Look at how he has been abandoned by his wife and their two sons, by his mistress and their son, by his longtime partner and their two daughters, and yet still he houses the poor. Still he raises thousands of dollars to buy new facilities. Still he roams the streets looking for people in need.

The mother of his daughters leaves him, it’s something else he must endure, it’s another sacrifice he has made towards a greater cause. He betrays another family member, it’s another sacrifice. His oldest son writes post after post on a blog read by people all over the world, and it’s a sacrifice. Just another credential in his revolutionary resume.

The only way he could save himself from being exposed as the person he was, was to create a fiction even greater than the reality. The only way for him to not be exposed as the man who abandoned his three sons, as a man who had sex with women who so deeply believed in his cause, who devastated the lives of the people who trusted him, was to lay down a foundation.

A foundation laid out in newspaper articles where he is sought out by reporters looking for quotes or sources from the serious man with the piercing blue eyes and the big white beard, both of which took up four paragraphs of a feature article on my father.

My father is not a cartoon, but every article quoting him might as well be quoting one. I don’t believe my father takes pleasure in hurting people. Especially his children. But it does feed into the image he has created for himself. Because of the choices he has made he no longer has a choice but to live in the misery he has caused, and it’s a misery which elevates his credibility in the one area he has left. And so long as no one steps forward to say “no, he made these choices. He did these things.”, his credibility will stand.

There is no one else. There are no other causes for any of this. Why did my sisters grow up without their brothers? There are no other reasons than the choices our father made. It wasn’t my mother’s fault he cheated on her several times, it was his choices. There was no other reason for the divorce than his choices. He chose not to pay child support, he chose not to have any contact with my brothers and myself.

My sisters deserve more, their mother deserves more, my mother deserves more, the mother of my youngest brother deserves more, my brothers deserve more, I deserve more than to have a father who hides behind the poor, homeless and disadvantaged people of the city which seems to want to turn him in a Saint.

My father runs a housing centre, a food bank, a youth shelter and a place where street kids can be creative… but what he can’t bring himself to do is make amends, or even attempt to make things right, with his own family who have done nothing to warrant even the slightest of his abuses.

.

...thanks.

.

Posted in Bipolar Disease, Bipolar Disorder, Clinical Depression, crazy people with no pants, Family, Father, Health, Living With Depression, Salted Truths | 7 Comments

Four Movies And Nine Pairs Of Socks

My psychiatrist’s office is in the next town over, so I generally rely on the graces of others for a ride every two weeks. The alternative is a $40 round trip cab ride with a driver who, more often than not, smells like rubbing alcohol.

I like to get into town an hour early so I can walk around. It’s not much of a city, but it’s ten times the size of my little village and has an actual “downtown”. Until this past summer there was a used record store I’d hang out in — a couple of years ago I sold four seasons of The Sopranos there so I could pay my heating and hydro bills. I could generally find something obscure but cool there, plus they always had a great selection of stickers and band logo postcards.

But they went out of business and now the only “record store” left in the area, other than the box store stuff, is a tiny, dark downtown pawn shop. The only time I was in there I bought two PS2 games. Their entire CD collection was stored in a small cardboard box behind other stuff on a bottom shelf.

Last year a really nice, decent quality video rental place opened up in town, and it’s right across the street from my psychiatrist’s office. So I’ve started buying movies instead. For less than $20 I can walk out with four used movies worth seeing a few times.

.

Continue reading

Posted in Appointment Day, Bipolar Disease, Bipolar Disorder, crazy people with no pants, Health, Living With Depression, Living With Manic Depression, Movies, Zombies | 14 Comments

The Hyperbole Of Hope And The Inevitability Of Change

This was originally intended only to be published on my [other] blog, where I’m trying to get back into the rhythm of writing news columns, but then I figured “what the hell”. So feel free to let me know if 1. the words are in the right order; 2. the words are written in English; 3. the general focus is coherent.

President Elect Obama won the election, yet Senator McCain didn’t lose so much as he came in a very close second. The person electors wanted to punish was President Bush, and they have.

The almost-former President’s place in history has been set in stone with this election. There will be no redemption. His will forever be known as the “Idiot Presidency”. Everything he “accomplished” will be forever eclipsed by the absolutely historic election of an African-American president. The Bush legacy will be reduced to books written about the lies used to get into a second Iraq war, and the disgraceful response to Hurricane Katrina.

Ding dong the wicked witch is dead. But she had been on life support for four years and wasn’t expected to live much longer anyway, so taking credit for her death after sticking a sword in a her lifeless body, and dancing on her grave after her body had already been put into the ground might be justified by the amount of relief which needed to be released, but it’s hardly a victory.

President Obama is a remarkable person, with a remarkable personal narrative, and his election to the presidency is an incredible testament to the historical narrative of the United States. But his election owes almost as much to American dislike, even hatred, of a president who would have been gone in a few months no matter who was running.

Continue reading

Posted in crazy people with no pants, Health, Politics, Punk | Tagged , | 19 Comments